SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS
Okay, now that you have had your chance to avoid any spoilers, let’s talk about June (Elizabeth Moss) not getting in the truck. I have read a number of folks who say that June SHOULD have gotten in the truck, that she should have taken that route to safety and that her job was to protect that tiny baby, that Hannah (Jordana Blake) was in a place where she was cared for and that June should have accepted her own chance for safety, then worried about Hannah later.
To that, I say, no fucking way.
You may think my response is a bit harsh, but I feel pretty harsh about it. Gilead is an evil awful place, and we have no idea how warped Hannah’s mind is ALREADY from her time there. The whole time that June was straightening her pink dress when she and Hannah had the arranged visit earlier in the season, I was about to crawl out of my skin. The pink dress may not necessarily mean that Hannah has been consigned to a life as a handmaid already, but there is that possibility. And June knows that.
See, I think that part of what the novel and the show has asked us over and over again to do is to think about the difference between making decisions that seem “right” versus making the decision that is actually good.
June’s mother (Cherry Jones) knows the difference and has always known the difference. Good decisions are hard, and they sometimes require sacrifice and make us uncomfortable and might even make people mad. A decision that seems “right” is one that looks good — it’s the one you can pick out of the list, easily. Good decisions are harder. But they are the ones that lead to the better long -term consequences in the end. They’re the ones you can live with later in your life.
I hear you, folks who are mad, June getting into the truck with the baby and Emily seems like the “right” decision. She could go to Canada with Holly and Emily, then find Luke (O-T Fagbenle) and Moira (Samira Wiley). From there, they could plot and scheme and try to overthrow Gilead. Maybe they would succeed. MAYBE. Or maybe they wouldn’t, and Hannah would have been abandoned by her mother and her father and left in a evil place. You think abandoned is a harsh word, maybe? How else would Hannah see it?
June made the GOOD decision. She put Nichole (Holly) into the truck with Emily (Alexis Bledel) and trusts that she has saved one child. Then, she puts herself, her potential happiness with Luke and Moira on the line to go back into Gilead in order to save Hannah. No, it’s not going to be easy. Yes, she might die. Sure. she might have had an easier time accomplishing this from Canada. But, I can’t imagine what life would have been like for June, waking up every morning, with Luke and with Holly and with Moira, but WITHOUT Hannah. She can’t either. How can she choose one child over the other? She doesn’t choose Hannah over Holly. She saves Holly… then she sets out to save Hanneh next. So, she walks away from apparent safety and heads back into madness in order to save her daughter. Luke and Moira are already in Canada. They can keep working from a place of safety. June puts herself in the line of fire to save her daughter. What a good decision I think this will turn out to be.
The whole season 2 has been setting this up. June has been consistently making decisions that we, as viewers, may have felt uncomfortable with, that if we had been given time to ponder beforehand, we might have advised her against. For example, what to do we think of June telling Eden (Sydney Sweeney) to grab love wherever she could find it? What about showing Eden’s book to Serena (Yvonne Strahovski)? Would we really have thought it was the best idea for June to slap Fred (Joseph Fiennes) if we’d given that moment a lot of thought?
My proposition is this: Season 2 is about all of us having to see how we to make hard, but good decisions. June had to learn that, and she learned it. From the examples above, let me explain how each of her decisions is actually good:
- Yes, Eden’s affair ends in tragedy. Two young people are forced into an impossible decision and an evil regime murders them. But June was right. We should choose love. What is the alternative? To be Fred? To be Serena? No. choosing love is the right decision. Eden and June were right. Gilead and Eden’s father were wrong, not June. Eden’s death is horrific, but that horror doesn’t mean that June was wrong about seeking love.
- Showing that book to Serena finally breaks through to Serena. How will they, the women in Gilead, raise children to know the word of God, that they care so much about, if these children can’t actually read the word of God? Serena may have lost a pinky but from that loss, she may have started a movement of her own. We have followed the story from the perspective of the handmaids, but none of the women in this regime have a full and valid role, including the wives and now these daughters. The only way that Gilead will fall is if all the women and all the rest of oppressed people there band together. We may not like the wives as much, but they are oppressed, too. June, by showing Serena the book, helps Serena become more aware of her own oppression.
- Oh, god, how much did I love that slap? Fred is SO CREEPY! I wanted to slap him the whole season. That slap was such a good decision. He slapped her, she slapped him back, and because of that slap she is put on more equal footing with him. I know you may be saying, “whaaa?” to this. But it’s only after this slap that Fred tries to bargain with June. He offers to keep her at the house, he wants dole out visits to Hannah, and he starts to see June as someone he has to make deals with. Her slap was a good decision, though I am not sure that June is willing to make those bargains, she at least moved to a position where she can bargain.
And her decision to walk away from that truck was good too. I know that what seems like the right decision was for her to protect that baby. And, she did that. Emily will care for Nichole (Holly). Emily is a badass herself. June knows that. June has TWO children. As she was walking away, I was thinking of Hannah asking if June had looked for her. How could June go to Canada when she had a chance to go try to save Hannah? No matter how wild or far-fetched that chance is? She had to stay in Gilead. She had to save Hannah. And, I think she will. Because Rita (Amanda Brugel) is right, and June is a badass.
Some other quick notes:
- No way is Aunt Lydia (Ann Dowd) dead. She was so perfectly evil this season that I hope she is more complex in Season 3. The aunts are the most unexplored facet of this society, and I hope they open that up more. How do you become an aunt? Who wants that horrible job? Unrelated, I wonder if we will ever find out Lydia’s real name. Or do they get to keep their real names?
- Speaking of names, I don’t think that June has changed the baby’s name to Nichole. I think she is saying that the baby should be called Nichole so that she will have some level of protection, as the Commander’s baby, in case they get caught. That’s my guess. She says “Call her Nichole,” not “her name is Nichole.”
- I don’t get the Colonies and how that is related to the economy. I’m guessing the Colonies will be a bigger deal next season.
- Nick (Max Minghella) holding that gun on Fred was such a big deal. I guess Nick will have to run, but I don’t think he will get far, which means we will likely be without Nick next season. That is too bad because I really like Nick and don’t want his story to end this way.